New York Assembly candidate Janet Tweed today called for legislation requiring tech companies to allow users to opt out of AI usage.
“The massive growth of AI data centers is driving up energy prices, straining municipal infrastructure, and threatening our natural resources,” said Tweed, who is also a Delhi village trustee. “This growth is being driven by a small handful of billionaires who have decided we should all be using this technology. But as I’ve talked with people of every political stripe across the district, many people do not need or want AI in their emails, web searches or social media. It’s actually astonishing how united people are about this, across the political spectrum.”
The New York legislature recently passed legislation enacting a one-year moratorium on the building of new AI data centers, a move that Tweed supports and urges Governor Kathy Hochul to sign. New York and other states have passed a variety of bills aiming to regulate AI usage, but Tweed’s proposal, to the best of her knowledge, is the first in the country that would require tech companies to give users the power to remove AI from their tech experience.
“Of course AI has some very beneficial uses, especially in medical and scientific research, but there is also a lot of slop and nonsense that adds no value and takes a tremendous amount of energy and clean water to produce,” Tweed said. “People who just want to check their email or search the web should not be forced to deal with AI-generated prompts and results if they don’t want to.”
Ideally, the federal government should enact such legislation nationwide, as data center opposition is widespread and growing across the nation. Since that is unlikely under the current administration, New York state should step forward to protect its citizens' rights to choose whether or not to engage with AI, Tweed said.
“Such legislation would need to be thoughtfully crafted to ensure fairness and transparency,” she said. “Ideally, we would require that AI prompts would not be generated automatically unless a user specifically opts in and asks to receive those prompts. And the opt-in/opt-out choice needs to be prominent and easily accessible. I don’t want this buried under six layers of settings menus.”
By: Janet Tweed, Delhi village board member, and candidate for NYS Assembly District 102
Albert Einstein said, "Whoever is careless with the truth in small matters cannot be trusted in important affairs." I’ve been pondering that concept over the past year and a half, as those in our current federal administration who have been entrusted with very important affairs have demonstrated such carelessness with truth, and with human life.
In the year 2000 – as I was beginning school to become a physical therapist – measles was declared “eliminated” in the United States, thanks in large part to safe, effective vaccines. Sadly, from January 2025 through March of this year, the United States has reported over 3,800 measles cases (93% among unvaccinated or vaccination status unknown patients). Three people have died from this entirely preventable tragedy, including two children.
Measles is one calamity among many wrought by this administration of salesmen, TV personalities and influencers, who have waged war against truth and against truth’s best defenders, scientists. The Trump administration has now fired the entire independent board that oversees the National Science Foundation. Parents who have been misled by careless influencers are rejecting vitamin K shots for their newborns – leading to an increase in babies dying from spontaneous bleeding in the brain. This dishonesty is harming our economy, too. Business leaders who can no longer trust the independence of the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ data are reacting cautiously: that loss of certainty caused $20 billion in lost industrial production, according to the National Bureau of Economic Research.
When I chose to enter the healthcare field, I was driven by the desire to help people, but also by the joy of becoming part of a field that is led by evidence, and continually seeking truth. There are bad actors in any industry, but as a field, scientists and healthcare providers have helped to create a civilization where we can live and stay healthy longer than our ancestors could ever have dreamed.
Those of us who value truth, and the tremendous benefits that the pursuit of it has brought to our society, must raise our voices in defense of science. This is one of many reasons I’ve stepped forward to run for New York State Assembly (District 102). Our policies – economic, social, healthcare and more – should be led by evidence, not by influencers. State leaders have taken critical steps to protect our communities now, as we continue to push for a return to normalcy and decency at the federal level.
But we can and must do more. The status quo, especially in our healthcare systems, is not working. While medical treatment guidelines are led by evidence, decisions about whether patients can receive that care are frequently driven by profit motives. If elected, I would co-sponsor the New York Health Act. Similar to Medicare for All, the Health Act would eliminate all for-profit insurance companies and replace them with one insurance agency, operated by New York, with no profit motive. Every other developed country in the world guarantees its citizens universal healthcare, and every one of those countries pays significantly less for healthcare, per capita, than we do in the United States. They also see better health outcomes, as their residents don’t delay or avoid care they can’t afford. Under the New York Health Act, 90% of New Yorkers would pay less for healthcare than they do now, while every New Yorker would enjoy access to medical, dental, vision, mental health, physical therapy and long-term care – with no co-pays or deductibles. Such a dramatic and needed change would take several years to implement, which is why the legislature should establish a commission to study and begin building the infrastructure necessary to enable this evolution.
There are so many other evidence-based interventions we can take to improve healthcare for our communities, including expanding school-based healthcare for all New York kids, mandating safe staffing ratios to protect patients and providers, and enticing providers to work in underserved communities by offering tuition loan forgiveness.
The attacks on science and evidence-based policy coming from the current federal administration are causing tremendous harm. But I am hopeful that we can make it through this dark chapter, and not just repair the old systems but reimagine new ones. We owe it to the next generation to try.
I’ve been a proud member of the Rotary for almost 10 years now, and I so appreciate the opportunities Rotary has given me to serve and build my community, whether through volunteering at pancake breakfast fundraisers, hosting an international exchange student, or giving away children’s books at Halloween. Rotary designates February as Peace and Conflict Resolution Month, a value and a commitment that is desperately needed here in the U.S. right now.
Like many of you, I have watched the behavior of ICE and Homeland Security agents in Minneapolis and elsewhere with horror and sadness. As part of my role on the Delhi village board, I serve on the police committee. I have the utmost respect for police officers who protect and serve our communities in accordance with the law, under the Constitution. ICE is not behaving like a law enforcement agency; they have become a lawless roving gang, terrorizing our communities with anonymity and impunity. A conservative federal judge compiled a record of 96 court orders that ICE has illegally violated, just since Jan.1 of this year. Law enforcement officers must obey the law themselves, or we are not a free country. I joined hundreds of my neighbors in Oneonta last Saturday to lift up those messages, and to stand in solidarity with neighbors who are feeling afraid and betrayed by the violence and injustice of ICE.
February is also Black History Month. As Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. said: “True peace is not merely the absence of tension; it is the presence of justice.” At the protest, a talented young woman sang “Stand Up,” the song written for the 2019 Harriet Tubman biopic. Tubman’s heroism in rescuing people from slavery, at risk of her own life, was evocative of the heroism we have witnessed from so many people in Minneapolis and elsewhere, who are peacefully resisting unlawful violence against their communities. In the state assembly, I will support legislation that strengthens human rights, builds peace and resolves conflicts, including forbidding law enforcement agents from wearing masks or otherwise hiding their identities – an unamerican practice that a separate conservative federal judge compared to Klan hoods.
I’m grateful for all of you who are standing up for true peace and justice, in whatever way you are able.
Finally, I can’t leave this topic without noting that February is also National Cancer Prevention Month, and American Heart Month. If you haven’t yet, please schedule your yearly physical with your primary care provider! The Affordable Care Act (aka, Obamacare) required insurers to cover this annual visit with no co-pay to encourage all of us to take better care of ourselves. The New York Health Act, which I would co-sponsor in the Assembly, would ensure universal healthcare for all New Yorkers and improve our health outcomes even further.
We are a people-powered campaign, participating in New York’s public campaign financing program. I will never accept corporate PAC dollars, which means I rely on support from people like you. If you are able to give, your donation will be matched on average 10:1 – when you donate here $5 becomes $65, and $100 becomes $1150. If you can't spare even $5, please know that I am running for State Assembly to fight for you.